By Michele Evans / NYweeklyRecord.com / Date: 11/16/2026
Category: Sentencing Reform / Criminal Justice / Community Impact
NEW YORK CITY, NY – Families, formerly incarcerated New Yorkers and lawmakers are preparing rallies across the state Tuesday to press Albany on three sentencing bills that would give judges more discretion, expand prison time credits and create a path to review long sentences.
The Nov. 17 actions are scheduled for noon in eight locations, including Brooklyn Borough Hall, Yonkers, Hempstead, Albany, Buffalo, Rochester, Syracuse and Ithaca. The effort is organized around the Second Look Act, the Earned Time Act and the Marvin Mayfield Act.
None of the three proposals has become law. Each remains pending in the Legislature, and the package will need support in both chambers before reaching the governor.
The Second Look Act would allow some people serving lengthy prison terms to ask a judge for a sentence reduction. The current bills, S.158 and A.1283, would open review after a person has served 10 years or half of the imposed sentence, according to the Communities Not Cages coalition.
A review would not erase the original conviction or guarantee release. A court would have to examine the record and decide whether a reduced sentence is warranted. That distinction matters in a debate often reduced to slogans. The bill creates a hearing process, not an automatic exit.
The Earned Time Act, S.342 and A.1085, would expand good-time and merit-time credits for incarcerated people who participate in education, vocational programs and other approved activities. The 2026 Senate session summary says the bill would increase potential good-behavior allowances and broaden merit-time eligibility.
Supporters say the existing system gives many people too little credit for sustained work and rehabilitation. They argue that meaningful incentives can make prisons safer and help families plan for reunification. Opponents are likely to focus on public safety, the seriousness of underlying convictions and whether the proposed credits are too broad.
The Marvin Mayfield Act, S.1209 and A.1297, would eliminate mandatory minimum sentences and restore more discretion to judges. Mandatory minimums require a set floor even when a judge believes the circumstances call for a different sentence.
Advocates argue that those laws shift power toward prosecutors because the threat of a mandatory term can shape plea negotiations. The New York City Bar Association supports the proposal and lists it as pending, along with the Second Look and Earned Time acts.
The person at the center of the mandatory-minimum bill’s name was a Harlem community organizer who became a leading voice against punitive sentencing after serving time in prison. The campaign uses his story to frame a broader question: whether punishment should be fixed by statute or evaluated by a judge who can consider the person, the harm and the full record.
Tuesday’s rallies will put directly affected families at the center. That includes parents who have lost children to violence and who still support a process for courts to recognize rehabilitation. Their position does not deny the harm behind a conviction. It asks whether decades in prison should remain beyond review even after substantial change.
Public safety cannot be treated as an afterthought. Any resentencing system needs clear standards, notice, a meaningful record and space for victims to be heard. Lawmakers should also be candid about who qualifies, how judges weigh rehabilitation and how correctional credits are calculated.
The three bills attack different parts of the same system. Second Look focuses on judicial review after years served. Earned Time addresses credits during incarceration. Marvin Mayfield targets the mandatory floors imposed at sentencing.
That is why the coalition is moving them together. One bill changes what happens in the courtroom at the start of a sentence. Another changes what progress inside prison can count for. The third asks a judge to look again after time has passed.
Albany has debated versions of these ideas for years. The rallies are designed to turn that debate into a deadline. For New Yorkers serving long terms and the families waiting for them, another session without action is not procedural delay. It is more time that cannot be returned.
Sources
amNewYork, Mass rally across New York state planned in push for sentencing reform bills
Communities Not Cages, Our Demands
New York State Senate, 2026 Session Wrap-Up
New York City Bar Association, 2025-26 State Legislation Status


Leave a Reply