NEW YORK CITY, NY – New York has agreed to pay $24 million to resolve civil claims brought by the family of Robert L. Brooks Sr., the man fatally beaten by correction officers at Marcy Correctional Facility in December 2024.
The agreement is expected to resolve a state Court of Claims action and a federal civil-rights lawsuit, according to a court filing reported by the Times Union. An attorney familiar with the matter described it as New York’s largest civil-rights settlement involving the death of an incarcerated person. The settlement must still be finalized through the pending cases.
Money cannot reverse what happened inside Marcy. The payment matters because it places a public cost on a death caused while Brooks was handcuffed and under the state’s complete control. It also leaves a harder question: whether New York has changed the conditions that allowed officers to use deadly force while other employees watched.
Six former correction officers pleaded guilty in the criminal case, including five who admitted to manslaughter. A jury later convicted David J. Kingsley II of second-degree murder and manslaughter. Other defendants were acquitted. Those outcomes established individual criminal responsibility for parts of the attack, but the civil litigation went further by alleging that supervisors and state leaders knew about entrenched violence and failed to stop it.
Earlier this year, a federal judge refused to dismiss Corrections Commissioner Daniel F. Martuscello III from the civil case. That ruling did not decide liability. It found that the complaint plausibly alleged he had received repeated warnings about staff brutality and concealment practices before Brooks was killed.
The state Department of Corrections and Community Supervision said the killing was a dark chapter and that it is pursuing reforms. The agency has expanded body-camera use and faced outside review of force, reporting and supervision at Marcy and other prisons.
Those steps need public measurements. New Yorkers should be able to see whether complaints are investigated faster, whether staff reports match video evidence, whether supervisors face consequences for concealment and whether incarcerated people can report abuse without retaliation.
The settlement closes major civil claims for Brooks’ family. It does not close the accountability file for New York’s prison system. The test is whether the state can prevent the next assault before a body camera, lawsuit or grieving family forces the truth into public view.
Sources
Times Union: New York to Pay $24 Million to Robert Brooks’ Family
New York State Department of Corrections and Community Supervision
Leave a Reply