By Michele Evans / NYweeklyRecord.com / Date: 11/19/2026
Category: Criminal Justice / Government Audit / Consumer Protection / Accountability
NEW YORK CITY, NY –
New Yorkers paid a mandatory fee to fight auto theft and insurance fraud. The state board charged with directing that money did not meet once during the three years examined by auditors.
The Office of the State Comptroller reported Wednesday that the Motor Vehicle Theft and Insurance Fraud Prevention Board held no meetings in 2022, 2023 or 2024. The board also lacked all 12 members required by state law throughout the audit period and did not have a quorum in 2022 or 2024.
Those failures had consequences. The Division of Criminal Justice Services, which administers the program, continued extending grant awards based on crime statistics that were nearly a decade old instead of using a current regional analysis to decide where money was most needed.
The program is funded by a $10 annual fee included in vehicle insurance premiums. State law directs the first $4.7 million collected each year to the prevention fund. From 2022 through 2024, DCJS awarded about $11.2 million to police departments, district attorneys, New York City fire and law enforcement units, and two nonprofit training organizations.
The fund still held nearly $9.6 million at the end of 2024. Auditors found that the board took no action during the three-year period to issue a new request for proposals or update its operating plan, which had last been revised in 2021.
The state was also late telling the public and elected officials what the program had accomplished. All three annual reports covering 2022 through 2024 missed the February 15 statutory deadline. The most recent report was due in February 2025 and was not issued until December.
A closer look at sampled reimbursements raised another warning. Auditors examined $324,214 in claimed costs from two grantees and identified $168,841, or 52 percent, in unsupported or excessive charges.
Most of that amount involved $162,124 in personnel costs that were not backed by the required time-recording system. Auditors also found 17 overtime requests totaling $6,449 that were approved by employees at the same or a lower level than the workers receiving the overtime. DCJS paid another $268 in overtime that a grantee submitted by mistake.
The audit did not accuse the sampled employees or grantees of criminal fraud. It found that documentation and approval controls were inadequate, leaving the state without sufficient assurance that reimbursement claims were accurate and properly authorized.
Participation was uneven. Twenty-one of the 28 grantees claimed only part of their awards during the three-year period, and one claimed none of its award. The comptroller warned that the cost of participating may outweigh the benefit for some grantees, a problem that could weaken the program further.
The same office reached similar conclusions in a previous audit. This follow-up finding is not a first warning. It shows that governance gaps persisted while motorists kept paying the fee and the state kept distributing money.
Auditors recommended that DCJS improve compliance with the law, restore effective board operations, address barriers faced by grantees, strengthen review of reimbursement documents and communicate contract requirements more clearly.
The comptroller’s public summary lists the findings and recommendations but does not state whether DCJS accepted each one. The agency’s detailed response is included with the full audit report. The public test is whether that response produces a functioning board, current funding decisions and documented proof that fee revenue is reducing theft and fraud.
For drivers, this is more than an Albany paperwork dispute. The fee appears on insurance bills, and motor vehicle theft can raise premiums, disrupt work and leave families without transportation. A program built to protect consumers cannot be credible when its oversight board does not meet and its grants rely on stale crime data.
Sources
Office of the New York State Comptroller: Motor Vehicle Theft and Insurance Fraud Prevention Program


Leave a Reply