New York courtroom with headline Judges Can't Cite Fiction

New York Bill Targets Judges Who Cite Fiction

By Michele Evans / NYweeklyRecord.com / Date: 11/18/2026

Category: Criminal Courts / Court Administration / Accountability / Ethics

NEW YORK CITY, NY –

A New York lawmaker wants to make one rule unmistakable for judges: the law cited in a ruling must be real.

State Sen. Michelle Hinchey introduced legislation this week that would classify the knowing or reckless use of fabricated legal authority in judicial writings as misconduct. The proposal, Senate Bill S10741, would apply to judges and justices across New York. It is now before the Senate Rules Committee.

The bill defines fabricated authority broadly. It covers nonexistent constitutions, statutes, regulations, court decisions, quotations, holdings, citations and docket numbers. It also reaches real sources that are materially misrepresented, including a false quotation, a distorted holding or an invented account of a case’s precedential status.

That distinction matters in a courthouse. A judicial ruling can take away liberty, money, housing, parental rights or access to public benefits. When a judge relies on authority that does not exist, the error is not confined to a footnote. It can alter the outcome of a case and force the parties to spend time and money correcting the court.

The proposed law does not ban judges from using artificial intelligence. It targets the finished judicial work. Under the bill, using AI by itself would not amount to misconduct. A violation would require proof that a judge knowingly or recklessly included fabricated legal authority in an order, opinion, decision or other adjudicative writing.

The New York State Commission on Judicial Conduct would retain its disciplinary role. It could impose sanctions available under existing law. The bill would also authorize the commission to refer a misconduct determination to the Assembly for possible impeachment consideration.

The proposal follows documented cases outside New York in which judges acknowledged that court orders contained fictitious citations or other material generated with AI. Reuters reported that judges in Mississippi, New Jersey and Oklahoma have faced scrutiny over such errors. New York’s court system adopted an administrative AI policy last year, but Hinchey’s bill would put a specific misconduct standard into state law.

The bill is not law. It has not passed either chamber, and no vote has been scheduled. The Commission on Judicial Conduct had not publicly taken a position when the proposal was reported. Those unanswered questions matter because a new disciplinary rule must distinguish a correctable mistake from knowing or reckless conduct.

The accountability question is simple. Lawyers already face sanctions when they submit invented cases. Litigants can lose their claims when they misstate the record. If a judge signs an order built on fictional law, the public needs a clear process to investigate the failure and correct the damage.

For New Yorkers in criminal, family, housing and civil courts, trust depends on more than a judge’s title. It depends on decisions grounded in law that exists, facts that can be checked and citations that lead somewhere.

Sources

New York State Senate Bill S10741

Official Bill Text

Reuters: New York Bill Would Punish Judges Who Misuse AI

Leave a Reply